As our herbaceous peonies enter their grand finale for 2013, we have already begun to plan our fall peony planting at Cricket Hill Garden. Peonies are very long-lived and relatively carefree provided that they are given a good start. Planting healthy stock is of course vital, but equally important is to amend the peony planting area so that the peony will thrive there. Basically, this entails adjusting the soil’s pH to the proper level and adding adequate organic material to deficient soils so that the peony will be provided with long-term nourishment. A little work now will pay you back with years of beautiful flowers. See our youtube video on this preparing a new peony planting area.

If you are planting peonies in a new garden area, choose a location with 6 hours of sun (tree peonies will also grow well in dappled shade, but if you are planting herbaceous or intersectional ponies, select a full sun location.) The other basic requirement for peonies is a well drained site.

When planting garden bed, make sure that the soil is deep enough to accommodate a peony’s extensive root system. Don’t worry if the soil is rocky, just don’t plant in an area with only a few inches of soil above a boulder or rocky ledge.

In New England, our soils tend to be sandy and rocky, as well as low in calcium and phosphorus. In our area the native soil’s pH is around 5.0 to 5.5, much too low for successful peony cultivation. Poor soils can be amended to improve fertility. Its always a good idea to have your soil tested so that you know your soil’s baseline mineral and fertility levels. The following list of amendments is suited for poor to average soils.
The following is a deluxe method for amending unimproved, poor native soil
if you are creating a new planting area.
We add 2 lbs each of the following soil-building amendments to our planting site sized 3′ x3′:
- Azomite– (long term minerals and trace minerals)
- Hi-Cal (Calcitic) Lime- For calcium, this also raises the pH of the soil, 6.5-7.0 is ideal for peony growing.
- Colloidal Phosphate- For short-term calcium boost and slow-release phosphorus, very important for bloom production.
- Greensand- For improving soil texture and adding potassium.
We add 1 lb. each of the amendments listed below for building high levels of humus:
- Alfalfa meal
- Blood meal
- Bone char
- These amendments can be found through suppliers like Espoma and Dr. Earth which package for the home gardener, sold online or locally at well stocked garden centers.
Rather than rotor-till a new planting area, we like to smother the grass and unwanted plants. By not disturbing the soil, we leave the complex web of beneficial bacteria and fungi intact.

One large wheel barrow full of finished compost achieves two goals, it adds organic material to the planting area and will also smother the unwanted grass.

Top off the compost pile with a wheelbarrow load of mulch. We have lots of old wood chips around the garden, so we use these. You might also consider using grass clippings or leaves.
Allow the soil amendments, compost and mulch to sit over the next few months. In the fall, when you are ready to plant, pull back the mulch and compost from the center of the pile and plant your peony there. All of the good compost and mulch will nourish the peony and get it off to a great start.
If your garden area has better soil and has been worked before, a simpler method which will yield good results would be to add 1- 2 lbs Azomite and one wheelbarrow load of compost to the future planting area sized 3′ x 3′. If you know your soil is acidic, add 1-2 lbs. of ground limestone. Allow this to sit and ‘stew’ over the summer and in early fall your soil will be ready for planting.
I have a roto-tiller, but I don’t use it unless I really need to loosen up soil for certain vegetables which grow better in very loose soil. What I generally think works best for me in these kinds of applications is my steel broad fork which goes down to 16 inches deep, about deep enough for planting new peonies.
It looks like you put a lot of effort into your new plantings eh.
One thing I’m surprised you didn’t add with all those ingredients is gypsum which is a soil conditioner that breaks up clay soil allowing roots to grow deeper, and take in more nutrients. It may not really be applicable if you don’t have clay soil though.
[…] The Cricket Hill Garden blog provides some extensive instructions for peony prep, including their “deluxe method” for getting the soil pH just right. Soil pH and adequate nourishment are the keys for getting your new peonies to thrive for many years to come, though choosing a full sun site with good drainage is also important. […]
[…] beds will ensure good drainage. For detailed information on soil preparation for peonies, see our blog post or watch our video on this […]